A man with a magnifying glass surrounded by ethereal representations of deception and manipulation.

Introduction

Social engineering attacks exploit human psychology rather than technological vulnerabilities, making them a significant threat in the digital age. Cybercriminals use tactics such as manipulation, deception, and trickery to breach security defenses. These attacks can be devastating due to their ability to bypass even the most sophisticated technical safeguards by targeting the human element within organizations.

Key takeaway: This article explores various types of social engineering attacks and provides effective strategies to protect yourself and your organization against them.

In today’s interconnected world, it is crucial to understand these threats and develop robust defensive measures. Trusted cybersecurity partners like Responsible Cyber, who offer state-of-the-art, AI-enhanced solutions including platforms like RiskImmune, are essential in helping mitigate these risks.

These platforms provide cutting-edge tools designed to identify, assess, and mitigate risks associated with external partners and vendors. With seamless integration, real-time monitoring, and comprehensive risk analysis, they safeguard your operations and enhance compliance. By optimizing your third-party interactions through solutions like RiskImmune, you can build a resilient business foundation and stay ahead of potential threats.

Stay vigilant, stay protected.

Understanding Social Engineering Attacks

Social engineering attacks exploit human psychology rather than technological vulnerabilities. Attackers manipulate individuals to reveal confidential information or perform actions that compromise security. These attacks are a significant threat in the digital age due to their deceptive nature and the increasing sophistication of cybercriminals.

Key Elements of Social Engineering Attacks

  1. Reconnaissance: Attackers gather information about their target, such as personal details, social connections, and organizational roles.
  2. Trust Building: Cybercriminals establish trust by posing as legitimate entities or individuals familiar to the victim.
  3. Manipulation: Using psychological tactics, attackers deceive their targets into divulging sensitive information or performing actions that benefit the attacker.

Techniques Utilized

  • Pretexting: Crafting a believable scenario to obtain information.
  • Phishing: Sending fraudulent emails to trick victims into providing credentials.
  • Baiting: Offering something enticing to lure victims into revealing information.

Example Scenario

An attacker might pose as an IT support specialist, contacting employees and requesting login credentials to “fix” a non-existent issue. The sense of urgency and authoritative tone often compels employees to comply without verifying the request’s authenticity.

Why These Attacks Succeed

Human nature plays a crucial role in the success of social engineering attacks. Factors include:

  • Trust: People tend to trust familiar entities or authoritative figures.
  • Greed: Enticing offers can override better judgment.
  • Fear: Urgent threats prompt hasty decisions without verification.

Relevance Today

The IBM 2023 Cost of a Data Breach report highlights that social engineering accounts for 98% of cyber-attacks, with an average cost of $4.5 million per breach. The evolving tactics and increasingly sophisticated techniques used by attackers make awareness and proactive defense essential for individuals and organizations alike.

Responsible Cyber provides expert guidance and tools to help businesses recognize these threats and implement effective defensive strategies, ensuring robust protection against social engineering attacks.

1. Phishing

Phishing is the most common and widely used type of social engineering attack. It involves using deceptive tactics to trick people into sharing sensitive information like usernames, passwords, and financial details.

Real-Life Examples and In-Depth Analysis

Phishing attacks often pretend to be legitimate messages from trusted sources. Here are some examples:

  • Email Phishing: Attackers send emails that look like they’re from well-known companies such as banks or online stores. These emails usually have urgent requests asking the recipient to click on a dangerous link or open a harmful attachment.
  • SMS Phishing (Smishing): Similar to email phishing but done through text messages. These messages might claim that there’s a problem with the recipient’s bank account or that they’ve won a prize, trying to get them to click on a link.
  • Voice Phishing (Vishing): Attackers make phone calls pretending to be someone trustworthy like IT support or government officials, persuading victims to share private information.

One notable example is the 2016 phishing attack on John Podesta, Hillary Clinton’s campaign chairman. He received an email that looked like a security alert from Google and ended up entering his login details on a fake website. This led to the exposure of over 50,000 emails.

Common Characteristics and Techniques

Phishers use various methods to deceive their targets:

  • Fake Email Addresses: Attackers create email addresses that are similar to those used by genuine organizations.
  • Urgent Language: Emails often try to create panic by saying things like “Your account has been hacked” or “Act now: Update your payment info”.
  • Links and Files: Phishing emails may contain links that take users to fake websites where their login information gets stolen. Attachments could also have malware that infects systems when opened.
  • Personalization: Some phishing attempts include personal details about the recipient (like their name or job title) to make the message appear more believable.

Knowing how to spot these warning signs is crucial for reducing the risk of falling for phishing attacks. Always double-check the source of unexpected messages and avoid clicking on links or opening attachments from unfamiliar senders.

Responsible Cyber offers customized training programs and resources specifically designed to help businesses identify and handle phishing threats. Their expertise ensures complete protection against these widespread social engineering attacks.

2. Spear Phishing/Whaling

Spear phishing and whaling are more focused types of social engineering attacks. Instead of casting a wide net, these tactics specifically target certain individuals or high-profile figures within companies, making them more sophisticated.

Targeting Specific Individuals

Spear phishing attacks are carefully designed to look like legitimate messages from sources that the recipient trusts. Attackers often invest time in researching their targets on social media, company websites, and other online platforms. This enables them to create customized emails that appear highly believable and relevant to the receiver. For instance, an attacker might pretend to be a senior executive or a familiar business partner in order to ask for sensitive data or financial transactions.

Whaling takes this idea a step further by focusing on top executives and key decision-makers within an organization. These high-stakes attacks aim to exploit the greater access and authority held by such individuals.

Notable Case Studies

Several well-known incidents demonstrate the severe consequences of spear phishing and whaling:

  • Ubiquiti Networks: In 2015, this technology company fell victim to a whaling attack that resulted in a $46.7 million loss. The attackers impersonated Ubiquiti executives in emails directed at employees responsible for financial transactions.
  • FACC Operations: In 2016, the Austrian aerospace parts manufacturer lost approximately €50 million after attackers used spear phishing tactics to deceive the CEO into transferring funds.

These cases highlight how even highly secure organizations can be susceptible to these sophisticated attacks.

Preventive Measures and Best Practices

To reduce the risk of becoming a victim of spear phishing or whaling attempts:

  1. Verify Requests: Implement strict verification processes for any requests involving sensitive information or financial transactions. This may include multi-factor authentication (MFA) and direct confirmation via alternative communication channels.
  2. Employee Training: Regularly educate employees about recognizing targeted phishing attempts. Training should cover identifying common red flags such as unexpected requests, unfamiliar email addresses, or subtle changes in domain names.
  3. Email Filtering Solutions: Utilize advanced email filtering solutions that can detect suspicious patterns and flag potential spear phishing emails before they reach the intended recipient.

Partnering with trusted cybersecurity experts like Responsible Cyber can significantly enhance an organization’s resilience against such advanced social engineering threats.

3. Watering Hole Attacks

Watering hole attacks are a type of clever trickery where attackers target websites that their victims frequently visit. These attacks work on the basis that users trust certain websites and may not be as cautious about potential security risks.

How Watering Hole Attacks Work

Here is a step-by-step breakdown of how watering hole attacks typically unfold:

  1. Attackers identify websites that are regularly visited by a specific group or organization.
  2. They find a way to infiltrate these websites and secretly insert malicious code into their pages.
  3. The malicious code is specifically designed to exploit vulnerabilities in the visitors’ computer systems.
  4. When someone from the targeted group or organization visits the compromised website, the malware is automatically downloaded and installed without their knowledge.
  5. Once the malware is installed, the attackers gain unauthorized access to sensitive information on the victim’s computer or network.

Real-World Examples

Case Study 1: Government Agency Website Compromise

In one well-known case, attackers managed to compromise a popular website that was frequently visited by employees from various government agencies. They did this by exploiting a previously unknown software vulnerability (known as a zero-day exploit) in the website’s code.

As a result of this attack, sensitive data from multiple government agencies was exposed, leading to significant disruptions in their operations.

Case Study 2: Industry Forum Malware Infection

Another example involves an attack on a major industry forum used by professionals within a specific sector. The attackers strategically placed malware into files that could be downloaded from the forum, such as PDF documents or software installers.

When unsuspecting users downloaded these infected files, their computers became compromised, allowing the attackers to steal valuable data from them.

Strategic Nature

The strategic nature of watering hole attacks lies in their ability to target multiple individuals through a single point of compromise. Unlike phishing or spear phishing, which require direct interaction with each victim, watering hole attacks leverage trusted sites to cast a wider net, increasing the likelihood of successful infiltration.

Responsible Cyber continuously monitors such attack vectors to provide up-to-date threat intelligence and protective measures for its clients. This proactive approach ensures that organizations remain vigilant against evolving tactics employed by cybercriminals.

By understanding and recognizing the mechanisms behind watering hole attacks, organizations can better prepare and fortify their defenses against these insidious threats.

4. Business Email Compromise (BEC)

Business Email Compromise (BEC) is a sophisticated and highly targeted form of social engineering attack. Attackers use email fraud and impersonation techniques to trick employees into doing unauthorized things, usually involving money transfers or sharing sensitive information.

How BEC Attacks Work

In a typical BEC attack, cybercriminals follow these steps:

  1. Reconnaissance: Attackers gather information about the target organization and identify key people, such as executives or finance employees.
  2. Spoofing or Hacking: Using fake email addresses or hacked accounts, attackers pretend to be someone trusted within the organization.
  3. Deception: The fake emails often ask for urgent actions like sending money or changing payment details.
  4. Execution: Unaware employees do what the emails ask, leading to big financial losses or data leaks.

Notable BEC Cases

Here are some well-known examples that show how damaging BEC attacks can be:

  • Ubiquiti Networks: In 2015, this technology company was tricked by a BEC scam and lost $46.7 million.
  • Toyota Boshoku Corporation: In 2019, the Japanese auto parts supplier was defrauded of $37 million through a sophisticated BEC attack.

These incidents highlight the serious financial and reputational harm that successful BEC attacks can cause.

How to Defend Against BEC Threats

To effectively protect against BEC, organizations need to have multiple layers of defense:

1. Email Security Defenses

  • Use advanced email filtering tools to find and stop phishing attempts.
  • Set up multi-factor authentication (MFA) for email accounts to make them harder to hack.

2. Transaction Verification Processes

  • Establish strict verification rules for any money-related transactions, like needing more than one approval.
  • Encourage employees to double-check unusual requests using other ways of communicating, such as making direct phone calls.

By combining strong email security measures with careful transaction verification processes, organizations can greatly lower their chances of falling victim to Business Email Compromise attacks. Responsible Cyber specializes in creating and implementing these protective strategies, ensuring comprehensive defense against evolving social engineering threats.

5. Baiting, Tailgating, and Other Social Engineering Techniques

Baiting

Baiting leverages human curiosity or greed by offering something enticing to lure victims into a trap. Attackers might leave USB drives labeled with tempting titles like “Confidential” or “Salary Information” in public places, hoping someone will plug them into their computers. Once inserted, malicious software installs itself, granting the attacker access to the victim’s system.

Example: In 2016, researchers conducted an experiment where they dropped nearly 300 USB drives around a university campus. Astonishingly, 98% of the drives were picked up and plugged into computers by curious individuals.

Tailgating

Tailgating, also known as piggybacking, involves an unauthorized person following an authorized individual into a restricted area. This technique exploits human politeness or neglect for security protocols.

Example: An attacker might wait near a secure entrance and follow closely behind someone with proper access credentials, often pretending to have forgotten their own key card. Once inside, they could steal sensitive information or plant malicious devices.

Scareware

Scareware involves alarming users with fake threats to coerce them into taking actions that compromise their security. Pop-up messages might claim that the user’s computer is infected with malware and urge them to download dubious software or provide credit card information for a “solution.”

Example: A scareware campaign may present users with a pop-up warning about multiple detected viruses on their device. Panicked users might then purchase unnecessary software or provide personal details to resolve the fabricated issue.

Real-World Examples

  • Baiting Incident: In 2006, an attack targeted the Department of Justice by distributing USB drives labeled “Top Secret” in parking lots. Employees who plugged these devices into their computers inadvertently installed malware.
  • Tailgating Scenario: In one documented case, an individual posing as a delivery person gained access to a company’s data center by tailgating an employee who held the door open out of courtesy.

These examples underscore the diverse and often surprisingly simple methods attackers employ in social engineering schemes. Recognizing these tactics can be pivotal in safeguarding against such threats. Responsible Cyber can assist organizations in implementing effective preventive measures to counter these various forms of social engineering attacks.

Defensive Strategies Against Social Engineering Attacks

1. Awareness Training and Education Programs

Effective defensive strategies against social engineering attacks begin with awareness training and education programs. These initiatives are crucial for cultivating a vigilant organizational culture that can recognize and respond to threats in the digital age.

The Role of Ongoing Security Awareness Training

Ongoing security awareness training helps employees stay informed about the latest social engineering tactics. By continuously updating staff on emerging threats, organizations can ensure that everyone remains vigilant. Regular training sessions also reinforce the importance of cybersecurity practices, making them a part of the organization’s routine operations.

Key benefits of regular security awareness training include:

  • Enhanced Detection Capabilities: Employees become adept at identifying phishing emails, suspicious links, and other common attack vectors.
  • Reduced Risk of Human Error: With proper training, employees are less likely to fall for social engineering tricks that exploit human psychology.
  • Improved Incident Reporting: Trained employees are more likely to report suspicious activities promptly, enabling quicker response and mitigation.

Key Topics to Cover in Training Sessions

To maximize the effectiveness of awareness training programs, it’s essential to cover a range of topics that address both technical and psychological aspects of social engineering attacks.

1. Recognizing Red Flags
  • Phishing Indicators: Teach employees how to spot common signs of phishing emails, such as generic greetings, misspellings, and urgent requests for sensitive information.
  • Suspicious Attachments/Links: Emphasize the importance of caution when dealing with unexpected attachments or links from unknown sources.
2. Social Engineering Tactics
  • Manipulation Techniques: Explain how attackers use psychological manipulation to create a false sense of urgency or trust.
  • Pretexting Examples: Provide scenarios where attackers pretend to be someone else to extract information.
3. Reporting Suspicious Incidents
  • Established Protocols: Clearly outline how employees should report any suspicious activity or potential security breaches.
  • Immediate Actions: Train staff on immediate steps they should take if they suspect they have been targeted by a social engineering attack.
4. Case Studies and Real-Life Examples

Share real-world examples of social engineering attacks and their consequences to illustrate the severity and impact these attacks can have on an organization.

5. Regular Assessments and Simulations

Conduct periodic assessments through phishing simulations or other exercises to test employee readiness and reinforce learning outcomes.

Responsible Cyber emphasizes the significance of tailored training programs designed specifically for your organization’s needs. By customizing content based on industry-specific threats and organizational structure, your team becomes better prepared to face potential social engineering attacks head-on.

2. Implementing Strong Security Policies and Procedures

Developing robust security policies is another fundamental strategy in protecting against social engineering attacks. These policies should address both technical measures and human factors to provide comprehensive protection across all levels of an organization.

3. Nurturing a Security-Conscious Email Culture

Promoting vigilance when dealing with emails and online offers is essential for minimizing risks associated with social engineering attacks. Encouraging a cautious mindset among employees can prevent many common attack vectors from succeeding.

By integrating these defensive strategies into your organization’s cybersecurity framework, you build resilience against the ever-evolving landscape of social engineering threats. Responsible Cyber stands ready as a trusted partner in fortifying your defenses through expert guidance and tailored solutions.

2. Implementing Strong Security Policies and Procedures

Developing comprehensive security policies is crucial for protecting against social engineering attacks in the digital age. Effective measures to enhance your overall resilience against social engineering attacks should encompass both technical and non-technical aspects of cybersecurity. By addressing these dimensions, organizations can create a robust defense structure that mitigates the risk of such attacks.

Key elements of a strong security policy include:

  • Access Controls: Define and enforce strict access controls to sensitive information. Limit access to only those individuals who need it for their roles.
  • Authentication Protocols: Implement multi-factor authentication (MFA) to ensure that access to systems requires more than just a password.
  • Incident Response Plan: Develop an incident response plan that includes steps for identifying, containing, eradicating, and recovering from social engineering attacks.
  • Regular Training: Incorporate continuous awareness training and education programs to keep employees informed about the latest social engineering tactics.

Non-technical aspects should not be overlooked:

  • Employee Behavior Guidelines: Establish clear guidelines on acceptable use of company resources, email etiquette, and how to handle suspicious communications.
  • Reporting Mechanisms: Create easy-to-follow processes for reporting suspected social engineering attempts.

Regular policy reviews and updates are essential. As attackers continually evolve their techniques, so too must your defenses. Regularly revisiting your security policies ensures they remain relevant and effective.

Steps for maintaining up-to-date policies:

  1. Conduct Periodic Audits: Regularly audit current security procedures to identify vulnerabilities or outdated practices.
  2. Monitor Threat Landscape: Stay informed on emerging threats by monitoring cybersecurity news and reports.
  3. Solicit Feedback: Engage employees in feedback loops about the effectiveness of current policies and areas for improvement.

By developing comprehensive security policies that address both technical and non-technical aspects of cybersecurity, organizations can significantly reduce their vulnerability to social engineering attacks. This proactive approach, combined with regular updates and employee engagement, fortifies an organization’s defenses against evolving threats in the digital age.

Responsible Cyber can serve as a trusted partner in this endeavor, offering expertise in crafting and maintaining robust security policies tailored to your specific needs.

3. Nurturing a Security-Conscious Email and Offers Vigilance

It’s important to have a cautious mindset when it comes to dealing with emails and online offers. This is especially true in the digital age where social engineering attacks are prevalent. Attackers often use tactics like creating a sense of urgency or curiosity to trick people into sharing sensitive information or clicking on malicious links.

Key Practices for Email Vigilance

Here are some key practices to follow when it comes to being vigilant with your emails:

  1. Scrutinize Sender Information: Take a closer look at the email address of the sender, especially if it seems suspicious or unfamiliar. Be cautious of any slight misspellings or unusual domain names.
  2. Check for Urgency Cues: Emails that try to make you feel like you need to act immediately, such as using phrases like “Immediate Action Required” or “Limited Time Offer,” should raise your suspicion.
  3. Avoid Clicking on Unverified Links: Before clicking on any links in an email, hover your mouse over them to see the actual URL they lead to. If the link doesn’t seem related to the content of the email, it’s best not to click on it.
  4. Watch for Poor Grammar and Spelling: Many phishing emails contain mistakes in grammar or spelling, which can be a sign that they’re not legitimate.
  5. Verify Requests for Sensitive Information: It’s rare for legitimate organizations to ask for sensitive information through email. If you’re unsure about a request you’ve received, reach out to the organization directly through official channels to confirm its authenticity.

Tips for Offers Vigilance

When it comes to dealing with offers that you receive online, here are some tips to help you stay vigilant:

  1. Research Before Acting: If you receive an offer out of the blue that you weren’t expecting, take a moment to do a quick search about it. Look for reviews or any warnings about scams related to that particular offer.
  2. Be Wary of Too-Good-To-Be-True Deals: Offers that seem too good to be true are often just that – too good to be true. Approach such deals with caution and think twice before providing any personal information or making a purchase.
  3. Utilize Security Software: Make use of security tools like antivirus programs and spam filters on your devices. These can help you detect and block potentially harmful emails and offers.

Ongoing Awareness and Education

Taking these precautions is important, but it’s equally crucial to continuously educate yourself and others about social engineering attacks. Here’s how you can do that:

  • Stay updated on new phishing tactics and scam trends: Regularly seek out information about the latest techniques used by scammers so that you can recognize them when they appear.
  • Encourage employees to stay informed: If you’re part of an organization, make sure everyone is aware of the risks posed by social engineering attacks. Encourage them to stay updated on emerging threats and maintain vigilance at all times.

By following these best practices and staying informed, you can significantly enhance your overall resilience against social engineering attacks.

4. Maintaining Software and Data Hygiene

To strengthen your overall defense against social engineering attacks, it’s important to do more than just recognize specific types of attacks. Adopting good habits when it comes to software and data hygiene is crucial for minimizing vulnerabilities that attackers can exploit.

Regularly Update Your Software

One of the most effective ways to protect yourself against social engineering attacks is by keeping your software up-to-date. Attackers often take advantage of known weaknesses in outdated software to gain unauthorized access.

Here’s what you can do:

  • Automate Updates: Set up automatic updates so that all your systems are always running the latest software versions.
  • Manage Patches: Make it a habit to regularly check for and install security patches as soon as they become available.

Practice Secure Data Management

Another important aspect of maintaining software and data hygiene is implementing secure data management practices that minimize the chances of sensitive information being compromised.

Consider these measures:

  • Encrypt Your Data: Use strong encryption methods to protect your data both when it’s stored and when it’s being transmitted.
  • Control Access: Only grant access to sensitive data to authorized individuals who genuinely need it, following the principle of least privilege.

Enforce Strong Password Policies

Having strong password policies in place is essential for preventing unauthorized access to your systems and accounts.

Here are some guidelines:

  • Encourage Complexity: Advocate for the use of complex passwords that contain a mix of letters, numbers, and special characters.
  • Utilize Password Managers: Make use of password management tools that can generate and securely store unique passwords for each of your accounts.

Implement Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA)

To further enhance your security measures, consider implementing multi-factor authentication wherever possible. This adds an extra layer of protection by requiring users to provide multiple forms of verification before gaining access.

Take these steps:

  • Make MFA Mandatory: Set up systems and platforms in a way that requires users to go through MFA when accessing critical resources or sensitive data.
  • Offer Various Authentication Methods: Provide users with different options for completing the second factor of authentication, such as receiving SMS codes, using authentication apps, or utilizing biometric features like fingerprint or face recognition.

By consistently practicing good software and data hygiene, you’ll be building a strong foundation for protecting yourself against social engineering attacks. These habits are essential in today’s digital landscape where threats are constantly evolving.

Conclusion

The ongoing battle against social engineering attacks in the digital age underscores the necessity of a multi-layered defense strategy. This approach should seamlessly combine:

  • Technical Controls: Advanced security software, firewalls, and intrusion detection systems.
  • User Awareness: Continuous education on recognizing and responding to social engineering tactics.
  • Robust Policies: Comprehensive security policies regularly reviewed and updated to tackle evolving threats.

Investing in these areas significantly strengthens your defense posture. However, navigating the complex landscape of cybersecurity can be daunting. Partnering with a trusted cybersecurity provider like Responsible Cyber ensures that you receive expert guidance and comprehensive protection tailored to your specific needs.

Protecting against social engineering attacks requires vigilance, proactive measures, and an understanding that attackers constantly refine their techniques. By staying informed and adopting a holistic security strategy, you can safeguard your organization against these pervasive threats.

FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions)

What is the significance of social engineering attacks in the digital age?

Social engineering attacks are a significant threat in the digital age due to the manipulation of human psychology and technological vulnerabilities by attackers to achieve their objectives.

Can you provide an overview of phishing as a type of social engineering attack?

Phishing is the most common and widely-used type of social engineering attack, involving techniques employed by phishers to trick their victims, often through email communication and malicious links.

How do spear phishing/whaling attacks differ from other social engineering tactics?

Spear phishing/whaling attacks target specific individuals or high-profile targets within organizations and involve a higher level of sophistication. Preventive measures and best practices are essential to mitigate the risk of falling victim to these targeted attacks.

What are some examples of lesser-known social engineering tactics?

Lesser-known but significant social engineering tactics include baiting, tailgating, and scareware, each with diverse methods employed by attackers. Real-life examples demonstrate the range of these scenarios.

How can organizations enhance their overall resilience against social engineering attacks?

Organizations can enhance their resilience against social engineering attacks through ongoing security awareness training initiatives, implementing strong security policies and procedures, nurturing a security-conscious email and offers vigilance, and maintaining software and data hygiene.

Why is it important to partner with a trusted cybersecurity provider like Responsible Cyber?

It is crucial to partner with a trusted cybersecurity provider like Responsible Cyber to ensure comprehensive protection against evolving threats in the digital landscape. A multi-layered defense strategy combining technical controls, user awareness, and robust policies is necessary for effective protection.

Leave A Comment

about Responsible Cyber

Responsible Cyber is a leading-edge cybersecurity training and solutions provider, committed to empowering businesses and individuals with the knowledge and tools necessary to safeguard digital assets in an increasingly complex cyber landscape. As an accredited training partner of prestigious institutions like ISC2, Responsible Cyber offers a comprehensive suite of courses designed to cultivate top-tier cybersecurity professionals. With a focus on real-world applications and hands-on learning, Responsible Cyber ensures that its clients are well-equipped to address current and emerging security challenges. Beyond training, Responsible Cyber also provides cutting-edge security solutions, consulting, and support, making it a holistic partner for all cybersecurity needs. Through its dedication to excellence, innovation, and client success, Responsible Cyber stands at the forefront of fostering a safer digital world.